Daily living - Activity 10: Making budgeting decisions
Activity 10 assesses whether the claimant is able to make budgeting decisions, either simple - for example involving activities such as calculating the cost of goods and change required following purchases - or complex - for example decisions involving calculating household and personal budgets, managing and paying bills and planning future purchases. As with all the other activities, a claimant is to be assessed as satisfying a descriptor only if they can do so reliably.
The descriptors for Activity 10 are -
- Can manage complex budgeting decisions unaided. 0 points
- Needs prompting or assistance to be able to make complex budgeting decisions. 2 points
- Needs prompting or assistance to be able to make simple budgeting decisions. 4 points
- Cannot make any budgeting decisions at all. 6 points
Terms used in the PIP descriptors are defined in regulations and, in relation to Activity 10, are -
- “aid or appliance” - (a) means any device which improves, provides or replaces [the claimant's] impaired physical or mental function; and (b) includes a prosthesis;
- “assistance” means physical intervention by another person and does not include speech;
- “complex budgeting decisions” means decisions involving - (a) calculating household and personal budgets; (b) managing and paying bills; and (c) planning future purchases;
- “prompting” means reminding, encouraging or explaining by another person;
- “simple budgeting decisions” means decisions involving - (a) calculating the cost of goods; and (b) calculating change required after a purchase;
- “unaided” means without - (a) the use of an aid or appliance; or (b) supervision, prompting or assistance.
See also DWP guidance on Activity 10 in section 2.3 of the Personal Independence Payment assessment guide for assessment providers.
Commentary: The definitions of ‘simple’ and ‘complex’ budgeting decisions are considered in the unpublished case CPIP/3015/2016 where the judge finds only those with significant cognitive/intellectual impairment should satisfy the descriptor for simple budgeting decisions. In contrast the concept of 'complex budgeting decision' is held to measure a wider range of abilities such as planning and calculating budgets, and in turn a wider range of conditions may cause functional loss. The unpublished case CPIP/184/2016 held that the assessment of the 'making budgeting decisions' activity requires 'a focus on intellectual capacity’ rather than taking account of any physical difficulties that may arise in managing the practicalities of a claimant's finances. | Add commentary or suggest an edit.
Claimant qualifies for highest-scoring descriptors under Activity 8 and Activity 10 if they are unable to accomplish what is involved in next highest-scoring descriptor
-  UKUT 79 (AAC)
Relationship between descriptors, and definition of key terms, in activity 8 ‘Reading and understanding signs, symbols and words’ and activity 10 ‘Making budgeting decisions’
-  UKUT 1 (AAC)
Inability to complete complex budgeting decisions where claimant has ability and motivation to complete other tasks / potential relevance of prompting in order to take nutrition
-  UKUT 169 (AAC)
Choosing clean clothes and dressing to an acceptable standard / impulsive spending may satisfy descriptor for making complex budgeting decisions
-  UKUT 156 (AAC)
Meaning and scope of therapy in activity 3 prior to March 2017 amendments / limitations making budgeting decisions may result from sight, memory or reading difficulties
-  UKUT 530 (AAC)
Limitations in making budgeting decisions may flow from physical disabilities alone but only in rare cases
-  UKUT 393 (AAC)